The Autopsy of a Failed Project: 5 Common Traps I’ve Seen (and How to Avoid Them)
“Luke, we need to restart. The last agency built something we can’t use.”
I hear this more often than I’d like. It’s heartbreaking to see a business owner spend six months and $50k on a product that ends up being a paperweight. When I step in to rescue these projects, I usually find the same set of “lethal errors” buried under the surface.
If you are planning a digital project—whether it’s a simple website, an e-commerce platform, or a custom SaaS—you need to understand the anatomy of failure. Most people blame “bad luck,” but in software engineering, failure is almost always predictable.
Here are the five common points that kill projects, and how you can ensure yours isn’t next.
1. The “Perfect Product” Trap (Over-Engineering)
This is the #1 killer of startups and new initiatives. I call it the “Feature Greed” syndrome.
A business owner wants to build an app. They spend three months thinking about every possible scenario: “What if the user wants to login with their Apple Watch?” “What if we need a dark mode that triggers based on their local weather?”
The Reality
You end up spending your entire budget building “nice-to-have” features while the “must-have” core remains buggy or unfinished. Software is never finished; it’s only released.
Luke’s Advice: Aim for a Minimum Viable Product (MVP). Focus on the ONE problem your project solves better than anyone else. Launch it. Listen to real users. Then, and only then, build the Apple Watch login.
2. The Communication Chasm (Assumptions)
In my experience, the biggest technical bugs aren’t in the code—they are in the requirements.
- Client says: “I want a simple login.”
- Developer hears: “Use Google Auth.”
- Reality: Client wanted a custom magic-link system with two-factor authentication.
The Reality
If it isn’t written down and visualized, it doesn’t exist. Many projects fail because the client “assumed” a feature was included, and the developer “assumed” it wasn’t.
Luke’s Advice: Never start a project without a Functional Specification Document (FSD) and Wireframes. If you can’t see the “skeleton” of the app in a drawing, don’t write the code. Documentation is the only bridge across the communication chasm.
3. The “Black Box” Syndrome (Lack of Transparency)
Some agencies treat development like a secret ritual. You give them money, they disappear for three months, and then they reappear with a “finished” product.
The Reality
This is a recipe for disaster. Development should be an iterative process. If you wait until the end to see the product, you’ll find that 40% of it is “wrong” because the market changed or a misunderstanding was baked into the foundation.
Luke’s Advice: Demand Milestones and Weekly Demos. You should be able to see a “staging” version of your project as it’s being built. If your developer won’t show you the progress until it’s “done,” run away.
4. Underestimating the “Aftermath” (The Maintenance Gap)
People think of a website like a house: you build it, you move in, and you’re done. In reality, a digital project is more like a garden. If you don’t water it, pull the weeds, and prune the bushes, it will die in six months.
The Reality
Projects fail because the budget was 100% spent on building, with 0% reserved for operating.
- Security patches need to be applied.
- Browsers update and break old layouts.
- Content needs to be refreshed.
Luke’s Advice: Factor in a 15-20% annual maintenance cost. If you can’t afford to maintain the project, you can’t afford to build it. A stagnant website is often worse than no website at all—it signals to customers that your business is inactive.
5. Choosing the Wrong “Foundation” (Technical Debt)
This is the most invisible killer. It happens when a project is built on an outdated or proprietary platform that makes it impossible to scale or exit.
The Reality
I’ve seen clients stuck with an agency because the agency used a “Custom CMS” that only they know how to code. You are essentially a hostage. Or, they used a “No-Code” tool that works fine for 100 users but crashes at 1,000.
Luke’s Advice: Build on Open Standards and popular frameworks (like React, Astro, or even well-implemented WordPress). Ensure that if your developer disappears tomorrow, another developer can pick up the code and continue. Your code should be an asset, not a liability.
The “Bonus” Reason: Lack of “Why”
Sometimes projects fail because they shouldn’t have been built in the first place.
I’ve had potential clients ask for a 15-a-month Google Spreadsheet. Before you spend money, ask: “What is the ROI of this project?” If you can’t answer that with a number, the project is likely to fail because it lacks a clear business objective.
Summary: Success is a Process, Not an Event
Digital projects are complex, but they aren’t mysterious. They fail because of a lack of clarity, a lack of transparency, or a lack of long-term thinking.
By focusing on the MVP, documenting your requirements, insisting on regular demos, planning for maintenance, and choosing the right tech stack, you significantly increase your chances of being in the 30% that succeeds.
If you’re currently stuck in a project that feels like it’s sinking, or if you’re planning something big and want to avoid these traps from day one, let’s have a coffee. I specialize in building projects that actually launch—and stay launched.
References: